Margaret Atwood Criticizes Alberta’s Controversial Book Ban

Post by : Bandan Preet

Renowned Canadian author Margaret Atwood has released a new short story that pokes fun at a controversial book ban recently implemented in the Canadian province of Alberta. This latest move by Atwood comes after her most famous novel, The Handmaid’s Tale, faced removal from some school libraries due to the province’s new rules on books.

Atwood, widely celebrated for her award-winning novels and thought-provoking storytelling, used humor and satire to express her concerns about censorship. She specifically targeted Alberta’s education ministry policies in her new story, highlighting the absurdity of banning literature.

The Alberta Book Ban

In July, Alberta’s Ministry of Education issued an order that school libraries must remove "materials containing explicit sexual content" by October 1. This rule affected numerous books, including classic and contemporary works that have long been considered important for students.

According to Alberta officials, the goal of this policy is to protect children from sexually explicit material. However, critics argue that the ban is too broad and restricts access to literature that explores essential themes such as human relationships, identity, and social issues.

As a result, several school boards have begun preparing lists of books that must be removed. The Edmonton Public School Board, for example, announced that over 200 books will be removed from libraries. Among the titles banned are Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale, George Orwell’s 1984, Maya Angelou’s I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings, and Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World.

Atwood’s Satirical Story

In response, Atwood created a short story aimed at 17-year-old readers. The story features two "very, very good children" named John and Mary. Atwood described them humorously:"They never picked their noses or had bowel movements or zits."

The story continues, showing that John and Mary grew up, married each other, and had five perfect children—all without ever engaging in sexual activity. Through this exaggerated scenario, Atwood uses satire to criticize the unrealistic expectations and restrictions imposed by the book ban.

She also directed her criticism toward Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, who has supported the ban. Atwood drew comparisons between Smith and characters from The Handmaid’s Tale, a dystopian story that examines control over women’s lives and reproductive rights. By doing this, Atwood warns against censorship and the dangers of overregulating literature in schools.

Atwood’s Ongoing Criticism

This is not the first time Atwood has spoken out against Alberta’s book ban. In recent statements on social media, she urged people to obtain copies of The Handmaid’s Tale before it could face public book burnings. She humorously warned: "Don't read it, your hair will catch on fire!"

Through these remarks, Atwood continues to highlight what she sees as an overreach in the province’s handling of literature and education.

Impact on Students and Schools

The ban has left many students, teachers, and librarians concerned about access to literature that encourages critical thinking. Books like The Handmaid’s Tale, 1984, and I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings are not just novels; they are important tools for understanding history, society, and human rights.

By removing these books, critics argue that Alberta is limiting students’ exposure to diverse ideas and experiences. Literature can help young people develop empathy, understand complex issues, and think critically about the world. With these titles gone from libraries, students may miss opportunities to engage with challenging but valuable ideas.

Comparison to U.S. Book Bans

Book bans have become a trend in the United States over the past few years, often targeting novels that include sexual content, racial themes, or political commentary. Alberta’s recent ban mirrors these policies, showing that similar movements are spreading north to Canada.

In the U.S., these bans have sparked heated debates about censorship, freedom of speech, and the role of education in fostering independent thought. Atwood’s story, therefore, is not just a reaction to Alberta’s policy; it also reflects a broader global conversation about the importance of literature and the dangers of restricting access to books.

Alberta Officials’ Perspective

Alberta officials, including Premier Danielle Smith, have defended the policy. They claim that some books removed from schools were inappropriate for children and teens due to sexually explicit content. However, critics say the list of banned books is overly broad, including classic literature that has educational value and has been studied for decades in schools.

The controversy also highlights tensions between provincial government authority and local school boards. Some school districts have struggled to implement the ban while balancing educational needs and freedom of expression.

Public Reaction

The public response has been mixed. Many writers, educators, and students have condemned the ban as censorship. Online, discussions about the removal of classic books have gained traction, with some encouraging people to buy, read, and share the banned books.

Atwood herself has joined the conversation, using satire and humor to engage readers while drawing attention to the seriousness of the issue. By crafting a story that exaggerates the effects of censorship, she demonstrates how restrictive policies can create unrealistic and absurd expectations.

The Importance of Literature

At its core, this debate is about the value of literature in education. Books like The Handmaid’s Tale and 1984 challenge readers to think about society, power, and morality. Removing such books deprives students of opportunities to explore complex ideas, learn from diverse perspectives, and develop critical thinking skills.

Atwood’s satirical approach shows that literature is more than just entertainment. It is a way to question authority, understand human behavior, and imagine different futures. By using humor, Atwood encourages readers to reflect on the importance of free access to books.

Alberta schools have until October 1 to comply fully with the education ministry’s ban. As the deadline approaches, debates are expected to continue between provincial authorities, educators, parents, and authors.

While the outcome is still uncertain, Margaret Atwood’s story serves as a reminder of the power of literature and the responsibility of society to protect intellectual freedom. Her response encourages readers, especially young adults, to think critically about censorship and the role of books in their lives.

Margaret Atwood’s new short story is more than a humorous tale—it is a statement against censorship and a call to value literature. By addressing Alberta’s book ban, she reminds readers of the importance of free expression and the role of books in shaping thoughtful, informed citizens.

Through satire, Atwood continues to defend the right to read and the freedom to explore ideas, even in the face of controversial government policies. Her work encourages young readers to engage with challenging themes, think critically, and question authority, highlighting why literature remains an essential part of education.

Sept. 4, 2025 5:51 p.m. 114

Canada News Global News Education News